Philosophy

Dr. Louise Antony (UMass Amherst)

“Not Rational, But Not Brutely Causal Either: A Response to Fodor on Concept Acquisition”

Abstract: Jerry Fodor has argued that concept acquisition cannot be a psychological or “rational-causal” process, but can only be a “brute-causal” process of acquisition. This position generates the “doorknob → DOORKNOB” problem: why are concepts typically acquired on the basis of experience with items in their extensions? I argue that Fodor’s taxonomy of causal processes needs supplementation, and characterize a third type: what I call “intelligible-causal processes.” Armed with this new category I present what I regard as a better response than Fodor’s to the doorknob → DOORKNOB problem.

For more information, please contact dept@phil.ufl.edu.